10 Common Composting Toilet Mistakes to Avoid

Have you ever thought about how a tiny mistake could turn your eco-friendly bathroom dream upside down?

More and more toilet users, including myself, are turning to composting toilets. They’re a fantastic way to live sustainably, save water, and reduce costs. But, seems like, anything new, they come with their challenges.

It’s easy to slip up and make some common errors when owning a composting toilet. And these slip-ups? They can make your toilet less effective and even go against the sustainable spirit you’re aiming for.

Before exploring common mistakes, it’s a good idea to read up on composting toilet maintenance tips. This knowledge will equip you with the necessary skills to keep your system running smoothly and effectively for years to come.

So, let me share the top 10 composting toilet mistakes you should watch out for.

Affiliate Disclaimer:

This article contains affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase through the links in this article, we will make a small commission. This is at no extra cost to you.

Why Understanding Composting Toilet Mistakes Matters

composting toilet mistakes an image of a composting toilet overlooking a serene like scenery

When you’re passionate about something, like I am about sustainable living, you want to get it right. Making the switch to a composting toilet is an exciting step towards a more sustainable lifestyle.

But just like any tool or appliance, especially if you’re going the DIY composting toilet route, using it wrong can lead to more harm than good. If we consider the complexities of managing liquids tank and solids tank, it becomes clear why it’s crucial to sidestep these mistakes.

Preserving the Environment

Switching to a composting toilet is all about reducing our environmental impact. But we can counteract the benefits if we don’t use them correctly. Mistakes, like not properly handling the solids bin or liquids tank, could lead to more waste, a higher water footprint, or even harm the local ecosystem.

Moreover, neglecting to add materials like coconut coir or peat moss can compromise the composting process. Let’s promise our planet we’ll do our best to make our eco-friendly choices genuinely beneficial.

Longevity of the Toilet System

Investing in a composting toilet isn’t just about the environment; it’s also about the savings in the long run. However, common mistakes can shorten the lifespan of our toilet system.

Simple missteps, like neglecting the trap door mechanism or not having spare parts, could mean replacing parts more often or even buying a whole new unit. I want my composting toilet to last, and I bet you do too. Let’s make sure we’re using it right.

Health and Safety Concerns

We all want a safe and healthy home. Believe me, when I say, using a composting toilet the wrong way can become a health hazard. From toilet smell to harmful bacteria, mismanagement, such as not emptying the urine bottle on time or leaving residual urine untreated, can lead to unpleasant and unsafe situations.

But don’t worry, I’m here to guide you through it. Together, we’ll make sure our bathrooms remain safe sanctuaries.

Top 10 Composting Toilet Mistakes to Watch Out For

Embarking on the journey of using a composting toilet can be both thrilling and daunting. If you’ve researched composting toilets, you’ll know that while it’s an eco-friendly and innovative solution, there are pitfalls many composting toilet users stumble into.

I’ve got your back, though. Let’s walk through some of these common mistakes and ensure you’re well-prepared.

1. Not Balancing Wet and Dry Materials

You’ve probably heard this before – balance is key in life. Well, it’s the same with composting toilets. One of the trickiest parts is maintaining a good balance between wet materials, like toilet paper, and dry materials.

Think of it like a recipe: too much of one ingredient can throw off the whole dish. If it’s too wet, it can become smelly and inefficient. Too dry? Your compost might not break down properly in the composting bin.

My tip? Always monitor your toilet’s content and adjust accordingly. Keep some extra bulking agent, like sawdust or coconut coir, handy to add if things get too damp.

2. Overloading the System

Enthusiasm is great. I love it. But over-enthusiasm when it comes to filling up your solids tank in your composting toilet can be problematic. Continuously overloading the system doesn’t give the compost enough time to break down in the compost bin.

It’s like inviting too many guests to a party in a small room – things get cramped and uncomfortable. Remember, patience is key. Allow your compost to break down properly, and avoid the urge to overload.

3. Ignoring Ventilation Needs

Have you ever been in a stuffy room with no airflow? Not the best feeling, right? Your composting toilet feels the same way about ventilation. 

Without proper ventilation, odors like urine smell can build up and the composting process in the black tank can slow down. Trust me, it’s not a corner you want to cut. Make sure you’ve got adequate airflow to keep things fresh and efficient.

4. Forgetting Regular Maintenance Checks

I get it, life gets busy. But forgetting to check up on your composting toilet is a mistake you don’t want to make. It’s like owning a car and not taking it for regular servicing. 

PPeriodic checks, like monitoring the liquids tank and holding tank, help you catch any issues early on and keep the system running smoothly. So, set those reminders and give your toilet the care it deserves.

5. Not Emptying on Time

Waiting too long to empty your composting toilet is a bit like forgetting to take out the trash – things can get messy. If the toilet is too full, it won’t function efficiently, and you’ll be left with more than just an inconvenience. 

I’d suggest setting a schedule for emptying your liquids tank or marking your calendar to ensure you don’t miss out.

6. Using the Wrong Cleaning Products

Not all cleaners are compost-friendly. Some can disrupt the composting process, or worse, harm the environment. Remember, it’s all about sustainability. So always opt for natural or approved cleaning agents for your composting toilet.

A simple solution of white vinegar and pure water often does the trick for cleaning without disrupting the composting process!

7. Improper Installation

We’ve all tried to DIY something and thought, “How hard can it be?” Well, when it comes to composting toilets, proper installation is crucial. 

Missteps can lead to issues like bathroom floor leaks or a malfunctioning trap door.

If you’re unsure, it might be a good idea to seek expert help or follow installation guides thoroughly.

8. Not Educating Users

If you’re hosting guests or sharing your space, it’s vital they know the composting toilet ropes.

If you’ve chosen to use a more basic setup, like a bucket toilet, or if your system comes with additional elements such as a urine jug, it’s crucial to educate anyone who might be using them.

Think about it: you wouldn’t hand someone keys to a car without explaining how to use it, right? Each composting toilet setup can be unique, and a quick briefing can prevent confusion or misuse.

9. Skipping on Carbon Sources

Carbon sources like sawdust or peat moss are crucial. So, always have a stash ready to use when needed. They help control moisture, and odors and ensure efficient breakdown of waste. Skipping or skimping on these can throw off the balance in your compost. So, always have a stash ready to use when needed.

10. Overlooking Local Regulations

Lastly, it’s easy to get caught up in the excitement of going green and forget the rules.

Just remember, some areas have strict regulations regarding composting toilets and how you handle waste, be it in plastic bags or other means. It’s always a good idea to check local guidelines before setting up to avoid any unpleasant surprises down the road.

Overcoming Composting Toilet Mistakes

We all have moments when we wish we had a “reset” button, especially when trying to adapt to eco-friendly choices like composting toilets. Making a mistake with your composting toilet is human, but what matters is how you navigate and rectify those errors.

Let’s break it down:

  • Stay Educated: When comparing a composting toilet to a regular toilet or standard toilet, there are differences and nuances. Knowledge is power. Familiarize yourself with user manuals or browse online forums to grasp the specific needs of your system.
  • Stay Observant: Whether it’s monitoring the balance in your black tank or noting when to dump urine, observation is key. Notice a change in the consistency of the contents? Or perhaps an issue with the toilet seat’s alignment? These could be signs that your system requires attention.
  • Ask for Help: Just as you wouldn’t hesitate to ask someone about an issue with a normal toilet, the same holds true here. If you’re confused about the uric acid balance or are uncertain about using toilet paper or cat litter in your system, reach out. Whether it’s the manufacturer’s helpline, a local expert, or another owner, the composting toilet community is often very supportive.

Remember, it’s all about learning and adapting. With a bit of care and attention, you can keep your composting toilet in top-notch shape and contribute positively to our planet.

Benefits of Correct Composting Toilet Use

Using a composting toilet the right way is more than just following a set of instructions. When you do it correctly, the benefits are clear not just for you, but for our planet and your pocket.

Environmental Impact

A correctly used composting toilet significantly reduces water consumption. Think about it: no constant flushes, no wasted water. Plus, you’re turning waste into nutrient-rich compost, giving back to the Earth in a truly sustainable way.

Reduced Costs in the Long Run

With fewer plumbing issues and no need for a septic system, you’re looking at substantial savings. And hey, using less water? That’s a drop in the bucket—literally—when it comes to your utility bills.

Efficient Waste Management

Transforming human waste into compost means less strain on municipal sewage systems. Instead of sending waste away, you’re managing it right at home, turning a potential problem into a solution. 

For those with mobile setups or RVs, managing your gray tank and black tank efficiently, along with the use of composting toilets, ensures a smoother journey without the need for frequent stops.


Mistakes are a part of learning, but when it comes to composting toilets, some errors can be costly or even harmful. By recognizing and avoiding these common pitfalls, you’re not just saving money or reducing inconvenience; you’re actively participating in sustainable living. 

Staying informed about the maintenance and care of all parts of the system, including the freshwater tank, is essential to avoid unwanted surprises.

If this article struck a chord with you, I’d love for you to visit my blog. Dive into more insights on sustainable living and be part of a community that cherishes our planet.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Often Should I Empty My Composting Toilet?

It depends on the usage and the specific model. On average, for a family of four, a composting toilet might need emptying every 2-3 weeks. However, always refer to the manufacturer’s instructions and observe the waste levels.

Can I Use Any Cleaning Product for My Composting Toilet?

No, not all cleaning products are suitable. Many commercial cleaners have chemicals that can harm the composting process. Instead, opt for natural or organic cleaners, or simply use a mixture of water and mild soap.

Why is my Composting Toilet Producing a Bad Odor?

A well-maintained composting toilet should not produce any foul odors. If it does, it could be due to an imbalance of wet and dry materials, insufficient ventilation, or not emptying it on time. Address these factors, and the smell should subside.

Do Composting Toilets Attract Pests?

When used and maintained correctly, composting toilets shouldn’t attract pests. Ensure a proper balance of materials, and always use a tight-fitting lid. If you notice pests, it might be a sign that the compost isn’t breaking down correctly or that there’s a breach in the system.

Can I install a composting toilet in any bathroom?

Most composting toilets are versatile and can be installed in various settings, from regular bathrooms to tiny homes or even RVs. However, some models might have specific requirements regarding ventilation or space. Before purchasing, check the specs and measure your intended installation spot.

Similar Posts